And what a shocker that 2005 defeat was as Posh went down to non-league Burton Albion 1-0 in a replay.
The teams had drawn the first game 0-0 at London Road.
Mark Wright was the Posh manager at the time with his old Liverpool teammate Nigel Clough in charge at Burton.
The result put travelling Posh fans in a foul mood.
Wright wasn’t best pleased either. He came out to see the press at 11pm.

5. BIGGEST GATE
The biggest Posh FA Cup gate at London Road is 30,096 for the fifth round visit of Swansea Town in 1965 which followed the historic win over Arsenal. It is also the highest attendance in any competition for a Posh home game. The match against the Swans finished 0-0 with Posh winning the replay 2-0 thanks to two goals from Peter Deakin. Photo: No

6. BEST RUN
The wins over Arsenal and Swansea led Posh to the quarter-finals of the FA Cup for the first (and still the only) time in the club's history where they lost 5-1 at to Chelsea at Stamford Bridge. Vic Crowe (pictured) scored the consolation goal despite suffering a serious early injury in the days before substitutions were allowed. Photo: Express

7. BIGGEST AWAY GATE
The 63,635 that watched Posh in the FA Cup quarter final at Stamford Bridge is the second highest attendance in the club's competition history behind the 64,531 that watched Posh lose 2-1 to Aston Villa at Villa Park in a fourth round replay in 1961. Posh player Vic Crowe is pictured getting carried off at Chelsea. Photo: David Lowndes

8. MOST COMMON OPPONENTS
Posh have played Kettering Town 13 times in the FA Cup, although most took place when both were non-league clubs. Tranmere Rovers (9) are the next most common Posh opponents and Britt Assombalonga is pictured completing his hat-trick against them in a 5-0 second round win in 2013. Photo: david lowndes

