And what a shocker that 2005 defeat was as Posh went down to non-league Burton Albion 1-0 in a replay.
The teams had drawn the first game 0-0 at London Road.
Mark Wright was the Posh manager at the time with his old Liverpool teammate Nigel Clough in charge at Burton.
The result put travelling Posh fans in a foul mood.
Wright wasn’t best pleased either. He came out to see the press at 11pm.

9. MOST HAT-TRICKS
There have been 19 FA Cup hat-tricks (or better) from Posh players, the last by Ivan Toney (pictured) at Bradford City in a second round replay in 2018. Craig Mackai-Smith scored a hat-trick against Wrexham in a first round tie in 2007 and followed it up with four goals in the second round at non-league Staines. Ken Laxton scored a double hat-trick in a 9-1 win at Rushden Town in 1945, the biggest FA Cup win in Posh history. Photo: Joe Dent

10. MOST GOALS
The great Dennis Emery scored 33 FA Cup goals for Posh and once scored in 10 consecutive Cup games between 1954-57. The most FA Cup goals in the club's Football League era is 12 from Craig Mackail-Smith (pictured). Photo: ?

11. MOST APPEARANCES
Sir Tommy Robson has made the most Posh FA Cup appearances in the club's history with 43. Norman Rigby is next best with 41. Photo: David Lowndes.

12. MOST RED CARDS
Sagi Burton (pictured) is the only Posh player to be sent off twice in FA Cup matches, at Coventry City and at home to Tranmere, both in 2004, but in different seasons. Photo: David Lowndes

