Train knifeman ‘had delusion that his life was at risk from conspiracy by devil’
Anthony Williams denies 14 counts of attempted murder
A man who stabbed 10 people on a train was suffering from schizophrenia at the time and delusionally believed his life was at risk from a wide-ranging conspiracy by the devil, a court has heard.
Consultant forensic psychiatrist Dr Bernard Chin said he was “satisfied” that Anthony Williams was “suffering from an acute relapse of schizophrenia at the time of each of the alleged offences”.
Dr Chin, who has assessed Williams and had sight of much of the evidence, told Cambridge Crown Court the defendant said he did not recall why he was getting on the London-bound LNER train from Peterborough.
The psychiatrist added that Williams said “I just keep hearing ‘you’re going to get attacked’, ‘they’re going to kill you’ through the speakers of the train”.
Williams, 33, denies attempting to murder 10 people on the train between Peterborough and Huntingdon, where it made an unscheduled stop on November 1 last year.
He also denies the attempted murders of three people in Peterborough on October 31 and of a 17-year-old boy at Pontoon Dock DLR station in London in the early hours of November 1.
Judge Mr Justice Calver KC earlier told jurors that whether Williams carried out the attacks is not in question, but they must consider whether he intended to kill.
Dr Chin said a report by psychiatrist Dr Alan Smith, while Williams was in custody on November 2 last year, noted Williams thought there was a “conspiracy organised by the devil against him and everyone was part of the conspiracy against him”.
Gillian Jones KC, defending, summarising the report by Dr Smith, said Williams “had stopped his quetiapine, the medication, three days prior as it wasn’t working though he acknowledged the voices got worse after”.
Ms Jones said Dr Chin saw Williams in person at Rampton Hospital in June.
Going through his report, Ms Jones said Williams had contacted his GP on September 30 last year through an online platform and “had done so highlighting his deteriorating mental state”.
She said Williams had said his “medication wasn’t working and he wanted it to be changed”, and the GP “established he had only been taking 100mg and needed to take 200mg”.
She told the court the defendant was sent a letter inviting him to a meeting on October 14 but did not respond to the letter or attend.
Ms Jones said Williams contacted the GP again on October 23 “again reporting his deteriorating mental state”.
She added that he did not respond to the GP calling back, and he was offered an appointment on November 5.
Dr Chin added that Williams said he had believed “there was a conspiracy accusing him of being a nonce, a paedophile”.
Williams said it was “really bad during Halloween, it was getting louder and louder”, Dr Chin said.
He said Williams had “looked on TikTok and there was a video of someone stabbing someone”.
Dr Chin said Williams claimed he was “extremely paranoid” on October 31 and thought “people were after me, the cars were following me, I was going to get run over by cars”.
He said he brought knives from home and “went by the river as I know the cars couldn’t run me over there”.
Dr Chin said the defendant suggested the “voices said I’m going to be attacked”.
The psychiatrist said Williams explained of the train incident that “I was attacking people, they were real people, I had knives, real knives, and knew they were going to attack me”.
Dr Chin added that Williams said “I keep hearing ‘you’re a nonce’, ‘these people are going to attack you’ coming out of the speakers on the train”.
He said Williams claimed “I just needed to protect myself, it was me or them”.
Dr Chin said he diagnosed Williams with schizophrenia, and that was an opinion shared with a psychiatrist who was instructed by the prosecution.
Dr Chin said Williams “had what we call paranoid persecutory delusions, meaning he had ideas and beliefs that people were going to harm him and that this was an organised conspiracy that came about due to… the devil”.
Asked by Ms Jones about the role of alcohol, Dr Chin said it “wouldn’t have caused it, it wouldn’t have provoked it, if anything it may have made him a little more agitated”.
Dr Chin agreed that the defence of insanity was not available to Williams and it was “evident Mr Williams knew the nature and quality of his act and he knew what he was doing was legally wrong”.
He said there was “nothing to suggest that by virtue of his mental disorder that he wasn’t capable of forming the relevant intent”.
He agreed with Ms Jones that a “psychotic intent is still an intent”.
Ms Jones said Williams believed the “delusional premise that his life was at risk from a wide-ranging conspiracy by the devil”.
She told jurors: “I’m not going to call Mr Williams to give evidence.”
The judge, Mr Justice Calver, told jurors they must not hold this against Williams “in any way”, adding: “I will give you a direction about that in due course.”
He sent jurors away until Thursday, when he said he would begin the first part of his summing up.