A long season lies ahead for a poorly assembled Peterborough United squad and their rookie boss, but others are currently more culpable

The game itself was meaningless, but it still managed to throw up further proof of a side seemingly in terminal decline.

A 3-0 defeat at Luton Town in a Jersey Mike’s Trophy group match merely condemned Posh to an away game in the first knockout round. No big drama to be honest and certainly not an outcome worth kicking the cat over.

Harry Ashfield on the ball for Posh at Luton Town. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.complaceholder image
Harry Ashfield on the ball for Posh at Luton Town. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.com

But the way Posh were time and time again exposed defensively while offering no attacking threat whatsoever was horrifying. Those of us seeking signs of life or glimmers of hope were to be rudely disappointed. This is going to be one long season. If there is light at the end of a tunnel it’s an awful long way away. League Two remains the most likely destination for a poorly assembled squad and their rookie EFL boss.

Robbie Savage did manage to locate the only positives of the night, 90 minutes for Sam Hughes and 20 minutes for Nathaniel Joseph and Kurtis Simmons, in a fine, and lengthy, interview with BBC Radio Cambs last night. The boss doesn’t try and shorten interviews, he doesn’t bat away questions with non-answers like his predecessor, but he has one mighty job on his hands to convince us he can turn this team, one he didn’t help to put together, into one capable of survival.

Collin Andeng Ndi. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.complaceholder image
Collin Andeng Ndi. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.com

Savage has been dealt an appalling hand. The squad looks too young and too lightweight. The better players can’t stay fit. It would all test the skills of more experienced bosses than the one Posh have ‘took a swing’ on.

Those who believe they have recruited a top 10 squad have brushed aside the fact they were trying to build a defence around two worthy, but sadly injury prone, centre-backs, supported by a left-back from Walsall, a winger from Colchester Reserves and midfielders mostly with very little experience of the rough and tumble of League One.

It’s all been ruthlessly exposed in 13 League One games and now in a couple of cup matches. If Savage avoids becoming the fall guy for it all I’d be amazed, but, right now, others are more culpable.

OTHER TALKING POINTS…

1) I can only assume back-up goalkeeper Collin Adeng Ndi doesn’t train well. It’s disappointing, for us as well as him, that Posh have played three EFL Trophy matches, four Carabao Cup ties and one FA Cup match and the man from Southend has still yet to appear.

2) I would not have played anyone last night who might feature in a far more important game at Plymouth Argyle on Saturday. An 11th minute departure with another hamstring issue suggests it was a mistake to play Tom O’Connor at Luton, but his recent injury record also suggests it was going to go at some point and leaving a Trophy game early was less damaging than leaving a League One game early. It’s not a good look to lose one squad member in an under 21 match and another in a game with very little on it so soon afterwards though.

3) On loan Aston Villa man Josh Feeney has lost his form completely since making his Scotland Under 21 debut. He needs to rediscover it quickly as he’s likely to start alongside Hughes on Saturday. It’s been quite the drop off in form as Feeney was outstanding and defensively decisive in his early appearances, but now he seems confused and tentative.

4) Harley Mills paid the price for a couple of alarmingly ill-disciplined displays in a row with his absence from the matchday squad last night. The left-back had been asking for it, but last night proved he remains the best in his position at the club by some distance.

5) It was great to see 16 year-old Joseph and 17-year-old Simmons make their debuts at Kenilworth Road, but a poor side playing poorly is no place for youngsters. Bolu Shofowoke is the best of them, but he has floundered recently. The experiment of Shofowoke at centre forward last night didn’t pay off in a team that struggles to pass the ball forward with any accuracy or good sense. It might be why they go backwards so often.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice