National League Cup semi-final is beautifully poised after a thrilling first leg at Planet Ice

The National League Cup semi-final between Peterborough Phantoms and Sheffield Steeldogs is beautifully poised after a thrilling 4-4 first leg draw at Planet Ice on Thursday night.

The Steeldogs will start favourites to win the second leg in South Yorkshire next Wednesday (January 21), but the city side will push them hard again if they match last night’s levels of workrate and determination.

Cam Hough celebrates his semi-final goal for Phantoms against Sheffield Steeldogs. Photo Willow Florence Photographyplaceholder image
Cam Hough celebrates his semi-final goal for Phantoms against Sheffield Steeldogs. Photo Willow Florence Photography

Phantoms were 2-0 down after the first period, but a superb second period showing saw them take a 4-3 lead into the final session, courtesy of two goals from Luke Ferrara, one from top scorer Cam Hough and another from man-of-the-match Dillon Lawrence.

Phantoms appeared to tire in the final 20 minutes, but dug in and defended gallantly, although conceding an equaliser to a short-handed strike was disappointing.

Man of the match Dillon Lawrence in semi-final action for Phantoms v Sheffield Steeldogs. Photo Willow Florence Photographyplaceholder image
Man of the match Dillon Lawrence in semi-final action for Phantoms v Sheffield Steeldogs. Photo Willow Florence Photography

Phantoms welcomed Scott Robson, AJ Herring, Preston Tombs and Corey McEwen back to their line-up, but Tom Norton, Brad Bowering, Ralfs Circenis and Alex Rushby were amongst the absentees.

Steeldogs, meanwhile, utilised their connection with Elite League side Sheffield Steelers by icing Cole Shudra, a player with one previous appearance at National League level this season.

Phantoms created some good early openings and chances with Morgan Clarke-Pizzo firing over at the back post after good work from Hough.

Ferrara and Lawrence also went close, but it was the visitors who took the lead through CJ Garcia, who popped up on the back post to tuck his shot beyond home netminder Hayden Lavigne. And a similar play proved to be Phantoms’ undoing again a couple of minutes later, as Shudra found Liam Steele ghosting in to double the visitors advantage with less than nine minutes played.

But Phantoms continued to create some good openings and were unfortunate to go into the first intermission two behind, with Jasper Foster, Ferrara and Lawrence all testing visiting netminder Brady Parker.

Phantoms’ persistence paid off in the opening minute of the second period when Lawrence ripped an unstoppable shot into the far corner, and with 25:59 played the hosts were level as Hough netted from the team’s first powerplay opportunity after excellent link-up play between Janne Laakkonen and Ferrara.

Phantoms now had all the momentum and captain Luke Ferrara gave them the lead on 27:53 after accepting a class pass from Lawrence.

But back came the Steeldogs to tie the game at 31:18 when Shudra teed up Kyle Watson to score from close range, only for Herring to rob an opponent and send Ferrara clear to deliver an emphatic finish a couple of minutes later.

Phantoms started fast again in the third period and thought they’d extended their lead to two, but the goal was washed out with the referee’s whistle having already sounded, but the visitors slowly took control and home netminder Hayden Lavigne stood tall to deny Jonathan Phillips and Ben Morgan in quick succession.

Frustratingly Phantoms then lost possession when on the powerplay and Shudra stormed away before finishing well to bring the scores level again on 46.33.

The Steeldogs outshot Phantoms 20-6 in that final period, but Ash Tait’s men almost claimed a winner when Ferrara fed Lawrence only for Parker to produce an outstanding save.

It’s all to play for in Sheffield next Wednesday (7.30pm face-off), but before then Phantoms are at Telford Tigers on Saturday (7pm) and at home to Basingstoke on Sunday (5.30pm) in National League matches.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice