The 10 things that must happen for Peterborough United to challenge for a League One play-off place

Peterborough United have blown their chance of moving under the radar to join the League One play-off race.

If it was stealthy progress Luke Williams wanted – and the manager’s laid-back character suggests it would have been the preferred method – he’s been denied. Sixteen points in six matches has propelled Posh to within two wins of the top six. Those recent points have been accrued against teams with modest ability, but if Posh get something from second-placed Lincoln City on Sunday (January 4, noon kick-off) expectation levels will go through the roof.

Tom Lees in action for Posh. Photo David Lowndes.placeholder image
Tom Lees in action for Posh. Photo David Lowndes.

And that will bring a different sort of pressure. This young side, and their impeccably mannered and shrewd manager, have made a nonsense of relegation talk, but will they able to thrive under the much more intense spotlight which comes with promotion chatter?

HALF-TERM REPORT Posh have now played half of their League One fixtures. They have played every team bar Mansfield Town, while having met with Reading twice. Posh currently have 32 points (10 wins, 2 draws, 11 defeats) so they are on target for 64 points which would normally be a solid mid-table finish. Huddersfield finished 10th with 64 points last season, missing out on the play-offs by 14 points

Harry Leonard after scoring for Posh. Photo David Lowndesplaceholder image
Harry Leonard after scoring for Posh. Photo David Lowndes

The way the division is shaping up a mid-70s points tally might well be required to finish in the top six this season which you’d think would be a tough ask for Posh, but, after picking up one point from the first seven League One games, Posh have picked up 31 points from 16 games, almost two points a game which was always Darren Ferguson’s target for automatic promotion.

In 10 games under Luke Williams Posh are averaging 2.2 points a game. Keep that up and Posh would finish on 82 points. It’s unlikely Posh could make that happen, but this is a division full of mediocrity and largely devoid of quality. None of the top eight won on New Year’s Day.

10 things that must happen to give Posh a chance of promotion…

1) Under no circumstances must midfielder Archie Collins be sold. Posh have a lovely blend of central midfielder with the sheer quality of Matt Garbett, the athleticism of Brandon Khela and the power and aggression of Ben Woods, while Donay O’Brien-Brady has shown positive passing ability in moments, but Collins has it all as he proves in most games from his place in front of the back four. I get the temptation to cash in on a player who is out of contract at the end of the season, but to do so would be to show a distinct lack of ambition.

Matt Garbett in action for Posh. Photo David Lowndesplaceholder image
Matt Garbett in action for Posh. Photo David Lowndes

2) Stay positive. This must happen no matter what results Posh experience in the weeks coming up. Posh have lost more than they have won this season, but a lack of draws is a factor in the climb into the top half of the table. Posh should take a chance on losing a tight game in order to try and win it and under the current boss this approach is probably guaranteed. Posh must never lose their nerve and settle for a point, unless that’s all they need to clinch a play-off berth!

3) Wrap Tom Lees up in cotton wool between matches. What a trooper this 35 year-old centre-back has been. A lot is said about his experience and communication skills, but he’s also a tough defender who is pretty decent on the ball. Lees was signed on a mystery contract relevant to the knee injury that finished his season early last term and in every recent game he has ended up on the floor seeking treatment. Every time I fear the worst, especially with David Okagbue’s current injury woes, but every time he bounces back to his feet and carries on.

4) Attacking set-pieces must improve. I’m struggling to recall Posh scoring from a corner this season. I’ve seen some imaginative routines in recent weeks, and Posh should have scored from a simple one at Rotherham yesterday, but four others offered no threat. The home goalkeeper caught two of them which is always frustrating.

5) Keep the entire squad happy, well those you want to keep at least. It looks like a tight-knit group without any sulkers and Brandon Khela is a case in point. He hadn’t stepped on to the pitch for Posh since December 9 before yesterday, but his attitude after going on in the 71st minute was outstanding. He even scored with his second touch before speaking modestly after the game when he paid tribute to the one-on-one coaching he’s been receiving while out of the squad. That’s not the behaviour of an unsettled player. The Posh substitutes have scored eight goals between them this season. It could easily have been 10 as Harry Leonard was thwarted by good saves after breaking clear twice.

Archie Collins. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.complaceholder image
Archie Collins. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.com

6) The January transfer window is vital. In such a competitive division it will be interesting to see which teams gamble on squad strengthening in the next month. Posh are currently restricted by salary cap rules, but they will need a left-back, a centre-back and a centre forward in my opinion so getting rid of some deadwood quickly is crucial.

7) I wouldn’t waste money/time on a new back-up goalkeeper. Nick Bilokapic can be our number two for the rest of the season. He’s the one out-of-favour player I would keep now that Vicente Reyes has returned to Norwich City. Other positions are a priority. Posh were presumably paying some of Reyes’ wages so they have made a saving there already.

8) Stay focussed and start games better. Posh have no cup distractions so that will undoubtedly help with focus. An ability to play through a fierce press from kick-off, or to keep pumping the ball long into space for the ever-willing Kyrell Lisbie to chase, needs to be seen early doors as Posh have a terrible record when conceding the first goal (2 points so far). Lincoln will test Posh physically from kick off on Sunday and it’s important to get through the early part of the game against rampant opposition unscathed.

9) Play Garbett in a position where he will get as much possession as possible. He breaks tackles and lines so easily which then gives a pair of exciting, if raw, wingers to burst speedily into space, while Leonard has a happy habit of placing himself on the shoulder of the last defender.

Ben Woodsplaceholder image
Ben Woods

10) Posh have four indispensable players. Collins, Lees, Garbett and Leonard. Pray nothing happens to any of them!

My predicted League One final table

1 Cardiff City (champions), 2 Stockport County (promoted), 3 Lincoln City, 4 Luton Town (play-off winners), 5 Bolton Wanderers, 6 Huddersfield Town, 7 POSH, 8 Bradford City, 9 Stevenage, 10 Barnsley, 11 Wigan Athletic, 12 Reading, 13 Wycombe Wanderers, 14 Blackpool, 15 Exeter City, 16 Leyton Orient, 17 Mansfield Town, 18 Blackpool, 19 Plymouth Argyle, 20 Doncaster Rovers, 21 Burton Albion (relegated), 22 AFC Wimbledon, 23 Rotherham United, 24 Port Vale.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice