Despite holding a 4-0 lead over Sheffield Wednesday from the first leg, Posh were beaten 5-1 after extra time at Hillsborough before losing a penalty shootout 5-3.
It was a terrible defensive display from Posh who were taken into that extra time by a 98th minute goal.
KEY: 10-Brilliant, 9-Outstanding, 8-Very Good, 7-Good, 6-Okay, 5-Poor, 4-Very Poor.

9. KWAME POKU
Looked to have the beating of his man before the break. One smart shot was well saved, but he couldn't get into the game after the interval and eventually sacrficed for an extra defender as Posh tried to cling on to a one-goal aggregate lead 5. Photo: Joe Dent

10. EPHRON MASON-CLARK
Held the ball up well in the first-half and also forced two decent saves from the home goalkeeper. Struggled to get involved as the game dragged on, but was harshly treated by the referee in a vital moment in extra time. Substituted in the final minute in favour of a penalty taker 5. Photo: Joe Dent

11. JONSON CLARKE-HARRIS
A forgettable night for the skipper who will rue not clearing the ball more effectively in the 98th minute. Dominated by the Wednesday defence for the most part, although did score his penalty in the shootout 5. Photo: Joe Dent

12. DAN BUTLER (for Burrows, 46 mins)
Battled away at left-back after his half-time arrival, made some good blocks and delivered the free kick which led to the Posh goal. Unfortunately the one player to miss his penalty in the shootout 6. Photo: Joe Dent

