Despite holding a 4-0 lead over Sheffield Wednesday from the first leg, Posh were beaten 5-1 after extra time at Hillsborough before losing a penalty shootout 5-3.
It was a terrible defensive display from Posh who were taken into that extra time by a 98th minute goal.
KEY: 10-Brilliant, 9-Outstanding, 8-Very Good, 7-Good, 6-Okay, 5-Poor, 4-Very Poor.

5. RONNIE EDWARDS
He was a cut above his teammates all night. Strong, decisive, tackled well and more accurate than most with his passing. If it was his last one for the club it was a good one. 8. Photo: Joe Dent

6. OLIVER NORBURN
It was a struggle to impose himself on this game. He worked hard, but his passing lacked sharpness and he didn't win his challenges often enough. Scored his penalty in the shootout 5. Photo: Joe Dent

7. HECTOR KYPRIANOU
He made a couple of fine forward passes in the first-half, but he was nowhere near as effective as he was in the first leg, like pretty much all his teammates. Cautioned in the first-half and taken off early in added time in favour of an attacking player 5.5. Photo: Joe Dent

8. JACK TAYLOR
The star midfielder played well in the first-half when he created half chances for teammates, but he became sloppy in possession in the second half when Posh couldn't get out of their own half. More involved in extra time, but a disappointment overall when Posh needed him most 6. Photo: Joe Dent

