Gustav or Brad? Declan or Cian? Kyrell or Abraham? Who is winning the race for Peterborough United first XI selection?

Peterborough United manager Darren Ferguson reckons many starting places for the League One opener at Cardiff City are up for grabs.

Read Fergie’s comments after the 1-0 friendly win at Boston United here

Archie Collins in action for Posh. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.complaceholder image
Archie Collins in action for Posh. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.com

But is that really the case? The PT has watched every friendly game bar the Friday night draw at King’s Lynn Town and the 1-0 win at Championship side Ipswich.

Here’s who we think are winning the race to start at Cardiff City on the opening day of the League One season on August 2. Obviously Posh could yet sign new players who could walk straight into the first XI.

Brandon Khela (top) and Brad Ihionvien. Photo Jason Richardsonplaceholder image
Brandon Khela (top) and Brad Ihionvien. Photo Jason Richardson

We reckon a 4-3-3 formation will be deployed.

Goalie – ALEX BASS v NICK BILOKAPIC

It’s going to be Bass even though Bilokapic has done well in pre-season. Nothing at all has been seen of Will Blackmore.

Verdict: BASS

Declan Frith in action for Posh at Boston United. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.complaceholder image
Declan Frith in action for Posh at Boston United. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.com

Right-back – JAMES DORNELLY v CARL JOHNSTON

Neither has covered themselves in glory in the games the PT has seen so it could be a choice between the greater defensive nous of Johnston or the better technical skills of Dornelly. Cardiff away seems like a game for the best defenders.

Verdict: JOHNSTON

Left-back – HARLEY MILLS v ANYONE

Mills appears to be a shoo-in for this spot while Rio Adebisi remains on the sidelines. Youngster Noah Freeman stood up well at King’s Lynn, but he’s a right-back. Youngster Davon Gbajamo is a natural left-footer, but wasn’t involved in either of the last two friendlies so unless Ferguson throws in a curve ball and fields Johnston as a left-back Mills will play.

Verdict: MILLS

Centre-back: OSCAR WALLIN v LUCCA MENDONCA

Teenager Mendonca has done little wrong in his first-team outings this summer, but Wallin was pretty good in the second-half of the last League One season and he’s come back in great shape. Wallin has even added a set-piece threat to his game.

Verdict: WALLIN

Centre-back: SAM HUGHES v GEORGE NEVETT

Posh are trying to bring another centre-back to the club which would make the defensive situation more complicated. For now the club captain is threatened only by Nevett, who is injured, Mendonca or Fabian Claxton,. The latter two are too young. It’s inconceivable the skipper will miss out even if a new man does arrive.

Verdict: HUGHES

Midfield - ARCHIE COLLINS v JOE ANDREWS

A no-brainer between an accomplished League One performer and a promising rookie.

Verdict: COLLINS

Midfield: BRANDON KHELA v DONAY O’BRIEN-BRADY.

Khela has been a standout POsh performer so far , although so has O’Brien-Brady been if you believe chairman Darragh MacAnthony. We’re not seeing what the chairman is seeing and Khela’s athleticism and ball carrying skills make him an ideal foil for Collins.

Verdict: KHELA

Midfield: RYAN DE HAVILLAND v CHRIS CONN-CLARKE/O’BRIEN-BRADY

It could be O’Brien-Brady who joins Khela and Collins as the third midfielder. Conn-Clarke will only play if Ferguson needs a ‘number 10’, but he has shown very little even in his best position. De Havilland could pop up with a goal if he plays as an advanced midfielder and that gives him a great chance to play in this formation. O’Brien-Brady doesn’t play with enough attacking intent for us.

Verdict: DE HAVILLAND

Right attacker: DECLAN FRITH v CIAN HAYES

Frith has had lively moments, but not enough to challenge Hayes as yet. Hayes needs to find an end product more regularly or he will struggle to hold on to his place.

Verdict: HAYES

Left attacker: KYRELL LISBIE v ABRAHAM ODOH

Odoh is under far more pressure for his starting place as Lisbie has hit the ground running at a new club and scored a couple of goals in the friendlies. We suspect Ferguson will stick with Odoh, but in a game against a Cardiff side likely to see a lot of the ball pace on the breakaway could be important for Posh and Lisbie looks quicker.

Verdict: LISBIE

Striker: BRAD IHIONVIEN v GUSTAV LINDGREN

Both centre forwards have gorged on some lower level opponents this summer. They are dissimilar in style so this is probably the most intriguing battle for a starting place of them all. Ihionvien is more powerful, Lindgren is more naturally skilled and both have shown they can finish. The choice could come down to the perceived weaknesses of the opposition and the style of play Posh want to implement. It’s a tough call – and a third striker should be a recruitment imperative in our opinion – but we have fallen on the side of the Swede.

Verdict: LINDGREN

News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice