Dreams of an EFL Trophy three-peat are over for Peterborough United after defeat that poses more questions than the average cup tie

Peterborough United’s dreams of becoming the first team to win the EFL Trophy three times in a row were ended on Tuesday night with a 1-0 defeat away at Swindon.

It was an unhappy return to his first club in management for Luke Williams who will leave the County Ground scratching his head, more so than you might expect from an average EFL Trophy tie.

Gustav Lindgren had the best chance for Peterborough United in the closing stages. Photo: Joe Dent.placeholder image
Gustav Lindgren had the best chance for Peterborough United in the closing stages. Photo: Joe Dent.

While the competition is often used by all entrants as a chance to blood youngsters and give fringe players an opportunity to impress, Williams chose not to go in this direction. Five changes were made to Saturday’s side that were beaten at Doncaster but a number strengthened the XI.

David Okagbue, Carl Johnston, Declan Frith, Abraham Odoh and Harry Leonard came into the side in place of Tom Lees, Peter Kioso, Kyrell Lisbie, Jimmy-Jay Morgan and Harry Leonard in what was a strong side, to the surprise of many fans. You could even argue it was only effectively one change to offer an opportunity to someone considering Tom Lees needs to be handled carefully with a busy fixture programme coming up, Declan Frith would likely be a starter when fully up to speed and Odoh and Leonard have been regulars all season.

This meant that the fact Posh failed to break down the side sitting second in League Two all the worse as there were no excuses about personnel changes to fall back on. High-flying Swindon make six changes of their own but ran out winners thanks to substitute Ollie Clarke’s goal two minutes from time. With Luke Williams still perhaps yet to get a handle of what his best XI is, this match will have gone little way to helping him with that.

The defeat was Posh’s first in an EFL Trophy tie since November 22, 2022. On that night, Malik Mothersille scored twice as Chelsea Under 21s beat Posh 3-2 in the second round.

In an early worrying sign, Posh did not start the game any brighter than in recent defeats to Stevenage and Doncaster, allowing the hosts to dominate the ball in the opening stages.

After the opening 15 minutes though, Posh started to come into things and in a first half devoid of any pace and attacking quality, the best chance fell to Matt Garbett as he ran onto Johnston’s low ball across the edge of the box but could only guide it just wide.

Posh soon invited Swindon back into the game though with some misjudged passing out from the back, which get them into trouble on more than one occasion. The closest Swindon came to breaking the deadlock in the first half though came from Billy Bodin throwing his body at a teasing cross only to fail to make a connection.

The second half started in the same fashion and the hosts then created and missed the best chance of the match. Again, Posh were the architects of their own downfall as Abraham Odoh horribly spooned a clearance from a corner right up into the air. There was no distance on it at all, the ball fell almost exactly where it left his foot and there was Aaron Drinan to pick up. His crossed was flicked on by Jamie Knight-Lebel into the path of James Ball at the backpost but he could only smash over in a great position.

Swindon had made all of their changes before the hour mark, including bringing on former Posh man Tom Nichols, before Posh had made a single change but it was Posh who finished the stronger and put together a period of controlled possession and pressure.

The introduction of Lisbie from the bench after 65 minutes added fresh impetus and drove Posh forward but it took until ten minutes from time for a real chance to fall their way. Gustav Lindgren was slipped through on goal, chose to ignore a wide open Odoh and look for the far corner himself, only for Lewis Ward to get a hand down and top the ball wide.

That was as close at is got for Posh as Swindon stole it with an against the run of play goal. With just two minutes to play, Joe Snowden took a touch away from Mills in the box and simply laid the ball on a plate for Clarke to arrive and guide it into the bottom corner.

Brandon Khela saw a shot deflected over in the 92nd minute of the match but Posh did not come close to rescuing themselves.

Posh: Alex Bass, Harley Mills, David Okagbue, Tom O’Connor, Carl Johnston, Ben Woods (sub Donay O’Brien-Brady, 77 mins), Archie Collins, Abraham Odoh (sub Klaidi Lolos, 89 mins), Matt Garbett (sub Gustav Lindgren, 77 mins), Declan Frith (sub Kyrell Lisbie, 65 mins), Harry Leonard (sub Brandon Khela, 89 mins).

Subs: Vicente Reyes, James Dornelly.

Swindon: Lewis Ward, Will Wright, James Ball (sub Tom Nichols, 58 mins), Gavin Kilkenny (sub Ollie Clarke, 58 mins), Princewill Ehibhatiomhan, Jamie Knight-Lebel, Darren Oldaker (sub Aaron Drinan, 46 mins), Billy Bodin (sub Jake Tabor, 58 mins), Joel McGregor, Finley Munroe, Paul Glatzel (sub Joe Snowden, 58 mins).

Unused subs: Connor Ripley, Harry Gray.

GOALS: Swindon – Clarke (88 mins).

CAUTIONS: Swindon – Munroe (foul).

REFEREE: Dale Baines 6.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice