Different views on Peterborough United... 'lucky not to be relegated'......'They were not as bad as a lot have been making out.'
Peterborough United fans are still vocal on the 2025-26 season.
Here we have a pair of contrasting views.


From Peter Lloyd, former chairman of the Posh Supporters Trust, by email
Thank you for your insightful and obviously (to me anyway) dedicated work in reporting so thoroughly on the Posh and the other League 1 teams. I hope many others feel like me - that you do a great job. You must have had some miserable journeys back from quite a number of away games. I did.


I didn't get a chance to give my view on the season but am aware of your player ratings and the reported views of other fans.
We were lucky not to be relegated.
I would give top marks to Archie Collins and Alex Bass with Collins my player of the season, still by some way. Great anticipation and awareness and his defensive work was again outstanding - so many last ditch blocks and tackles and always kept his cool. I hope he goes to a top Championship club and plays a lot of games.
I would give a big shout out to Harry Leonard, Tom Lees and to Kyrell Lisbie. Without those five players we would have been relegated for sure.
We would have been relegated anyway were it not for the purple patch and fluent front foot play which took opponents a surprisingly long time to adapt to. They seemed to think we were going to be easy to beat all season. When they did work out how to play us - particularly to double up on Lisbie and sometimes on Collins and Morgan, and attack us down the flanks - then it pretty much stopped everything and we never had an answer.
As is usual for Posh it was the defensive side of the game where we were poorest - full backs constantly out of position and unable to cope with wide attacking players – constant mix ups and disorganisation - they were targeted all season. But we weren't as good as usual in converting good positions up front this time and the two together were almost fatal.
Credit to Carl Johnston for gutsy efforts out of position
Some credit to Peter Kioso for trying hard most of the time and blocking a lot of likely goals (i am not as negative as many others on what he did for us)
Credit to Leonard for really upping his game when he had such poor service. He seemed to be the one player who was determined that we would not be relegated.
Credit to Morgan although he faded out of games too often.
The coaching at Posh seems to be a particular weakness. Problems don't get sorted and so many players under par and weak in the tackle, then diving to try to get free kicks. Choices made by our wide players are too often wrong and don't get corrected. We are not well organised.
Looking forward:
Hopeful for Garbett who is all round class, but needs better players around him.
Hopeful that Bolu Shofowoke continues to be bold and develops more football nous with the help of the coaches
Hopeful for James Dornelly with better coaching too, but there is a good player in there
Hopeful for a full recovery to Harley Mills best level
Hopeful that David Okagbue can be coached into a very good defender, but he didn't let Posh down on balance.
Strengthening is obviously very important now and the necessary financial situation should be helped by the Ephron Mason-Clark promotion into the Premier League.
From John Clifton on X (@jcposh57)…
We had 3 months of top 6 form until 4 or 5 of our leaders got injured for 2 months. We weren’t poor all season as a lot are making out.
The squad on day 1 wasn’t good enough. Then we put things right, but it took the new players 4 or 5 games to get match fit. After a decent 3 months we lost O’Connor, Woods, Garbutt, Lees and then Johnston. Apart from them we had a very young inexperienced side.
Also players playing out of position with 3 right backs in the defence and we also lost Harry Leonard for March. We then had players coming back too early such as Lees and Mills because of the run we were on. I agree with our retained list.