A tale of the unexpected as Peterborough United claim victory with a battling display at Plymouth Argyle

Peterborough United confounded the rising tide of despair at London Road to deliver an outstanding 2-0 League One win at Plymouth Argyle on Saturday.

A superb first-half header from Harry Ashfield and an emphatic late thump from the penalty spot from Harry Leonard secured a first win in five League One games.

Harry Ashfield celebrates his goal for Posh at Plymouth. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.com.placeholder image
Harry Ashfield celebrates his goal for Posh at Plymouth. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.com.

But it was built on a super defence display, particularly from centre-backs Josh Feeney and Sam Hughes, which delivered a first clean sheet in 16 competitive outings.

Only a 95th minute goal from Doncaster kept Posh in the bottom four on goal difference, but it was still a morale boosting effort ahead of next Saturday’s derby at home to Cambridge United.

Harley Mills on the ball for Posh at Plymouth. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.complaceholder image
Harley Mills on the ball for Posh at Plymouth. Photo Joe Dent/theposh.com

Some rare good injury news arrived pre-match with striker Leonard declaring himself fit to line up in between winger Bolu Shofowoke and Owura Edwards.

Harrison Jones started a first League One game since the departure Luke Williams alongside Ashfield and Ethan Williams, a midfield of two 20 year-olds and a 21 year-old. Matt Garbett’s foot injury kept him out of the squad.

Full-backs Carl Johnston and Harley Mills were both back after injury and an axing respectively.

Plymouth had even more injury issues than Posh with seven probable starters all absent including top scorer Bim Pepple and a pair of first choice centre backs.They adopted a bold 4-4-2, old fashioned formation.

Posh had to deal with a lot of long balls aimed in the direction of Will Evans, but mostly they did it well, although the majority of the first-half chances went to the home side.

Posh thought they had scored with their first attack in the fourth minute. A cross from Edwards was handled poorly by goalkeeper Murphy Cooper and the ball fell kindly to Williams. He did his bit by knocking the ball goalwards, but it hit Bolu Shofowoke on the goaline and an offside flag was inevitable.

The hosts were straight down the other end with Hughes blocking a Caleb Watts shot and Xavier Amaechi striking the outside of a post with a curling 20 yarder.

Posh had some good moments in possession with Ashfield shooting over after a patient move, but the midfielder was on target with a terrific header on 22 minutes. Ashfield expertly deflected a right foot cross from Mills over Cooper’s head and into the net for his first League One goal.

A Feeney block of a Watts shot followed almost instantly and the same forward miscued badly when teed up by Evans 16 yards from goal.

Posh were comfortable for the rest of the half after that, until the final minute when ‘keeper Alex Bass tipped a far post Ronan Curtis header over the crossbar.

And it was even more comfortable in the second-half as Hughes and Feeney were dominant aerially thus neutering the only attacking tactic Plymouth possessed. In truth the match was very scrappy with little quality on show, but for once it favoured Posh who had the lead.

Only when a whipped free kick from Amaechi reached Mathias Ross on the stretch did Bass have to make a save. Shofowoke survived a handball appeal in his own area 15 minutes from time, but referee Carl Brook was proved right by TV replays.

And then, twice in added time Edwards streaked away. He fed Leonard whose blistering shot was well saved in the first attempt, but his second run was rudely interrupted by Cooper for the most obvious of penalties.

Leonard smashed it home to seal a most unexpected win, but one Posh thoroughly deserved.

Posh: Alex Bass, Carl Johnston, Sam Hughes, Josh Feeney, Harley Mills, Harrison Jones (sub Liam Kelly, 61 mins), Harry Ashfield, Ethan Williams (sub Brandon Khela, 80 mins), Owura Edwards, Bolu Shofowoke, Harry Leonard (sub David Okagbue, 90 + 4 mins).

Unused subs: Collin Andeng-Ndi, Vernon Masara, Patryk Sykut, Declan Frith.

Plymouth: Murphy Cooper, Mathias Ross, Jack MacKenzie (sub Seb Campbell, 83 mins), Alex Hartridge, Wes Harding (sub Joe Mwaro, 62 mins), Malachi Boateng, Harvey White (sub Bradley Ibrahim, 56 mins), Caleb Watts (sub Owen Oseni, 62 mins), Will Evans, Xavier Amaechi (sub Oliver Irow, 62 mins), Ronan Curtis

Unused subs: James Storer, Joe Mwaro.

Posh goals: Ashfield (22 mins), Leonard (pen, 93 mins)

Posh cautions: Mills (foul), Feeney (foul), Ashfield (foul).

Plymouth cautions: White (foul), McKenzie (foul), Ebans (foul), Cooper (foul).

Referee: Carl Brook 6.

Attendance: (to follow).

News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice