Restaurant review: Independent holding its own against the big boys

I do like an underdog, and with the arrival of the big, shiny High Street brand restaurants in Peterborough city centre, independents like Topo Gigio's certainly fit into that bracket.

So it was great to see, once again I might add, that the Cowgate-based Italian was enjoying a busy lunchtime, with a good 20-plus diners when I popped in on Friday.

Brad Barnes dines at Topo Gigio'splaceholder image
Brad Barnes dines at Topo Gigio's

In its current incarnation, Topo’s has only been around for just over two years - after being revived by Mick Guarnaccia -but still carries the name that harks back to the 80s and 90s.

And my lunch was also reminiscent of the great food I enjoyed there during its pomp, which seems like a generation ago.

Brad Barnes dines at Topo Gigioplaceholder image
Brad Barnes dines at Topo Gigio

The place has a rustic look which I like and a big open kitchen so you can see everything being prepared and coming out.

In addition to the pizza and pasta on the main menu, there is a set lunchtime offer - two courses for £7.95 and three courses for £9.95.

I started off with quite a generous caprese salad ( the alternatives were bruschetta or garlic bread).

It is traditionally made to represent the Italian flag - red white and green - and I wasn’t disappointed.

Brad Barnes dines at Topo Gigioplaceholder image
Brad Barnes dines at Topo Gigio

Layers of fresh tomatoes with a hint of sweetness, thick slices of soft and creamy mozzarella and slightly peppery basil leafs. A drizzle of olive oil and a balsamic reduction, with a little seasoning, it was very enjoyable.

The main course offerings were penne arrabbiata, cotoletta di pollo and spaghetti bolognese. I went with the latter, and I wasn’t disapointed.

It was a good sized portion, I liked the fact the spaghetti was near al dente ( I can’t stand soggy pasta), the mince had a nice meaty taste to it and the sauce wasn’t too heavy on tomatoes. Everything was just as I like it.

Just like the old days.

Venue: Topo Gigio’s, Cowgate, Peterborough 01733 685657

Brad’s rating: 8

News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice