Where did it all go wrong for Peterborough United in 2025/26? A season review of how Posh came the closest they've been to League Two in 20 years
Where did it all go wrong for Peterborough United in the 2025/26 season?….
Posh kicked off the League One season away at Cardiff on August 2 but did not have a fit and firing side at least capable of competing at League One level until the middle of September. September 13- a 2-1 home victory over Wycombe- brought the first three points of the campaign after eight defeats and a solitary draw in all competitions.


On that day, Tom Lees, Tom O’Connor, Matt Garbett, Jimmy-Jay Morgan and Harry Leonard all featured- Garbett and Morgan provided the goals- yet none of them were even in the building ahead of opening day.
Whether it was an issue with freeing up cash or simply misplaced faith that led Posh to line-up in Wales with: Bilokapic; Johnston, Wallin, Okagbue, Mills; Collins, Khela; Frith, O’Brien-Brady, Odoh; Ihionvien, we may never know but the pre-season preparations- or lack thereof- put Posh on the backfoot from the start.
Leonard, Morgan, O’Connor and Mendy were panic signings on Deadline Day but thank goodness Posh did panic or else fans would be planning trips to Crewe, Gillingham and Northampton next season.
In truth, groans began long before opening day when, on the back of an 18th place finish having made the play-offs the season previous, Posh released a retained list on which only four player were made available for transfer; Jack Sparkes, Jacob Wakeling along with Bilokapic and Ihionvien. The latter two both started at Cardiff!
Posh quickly began to rue faith shown in the likes of Abraham Odoh, Cian Hayes, Gustav Lindgren, Ryan De Havilland and Chris Conn-Clarke. It was not earned or re-paid. All of their careers at Posh are set to be swiftly forgotten as they proved poor imitations of their predecessors Kwame Poku, Hector Kyprianou and Ricky-Jade Jones et al. Fans were told that so many would improve in ‘year two’ so to hear the chairman saying the same again is worrying to say the least.
Ferguson was dealt cruel blows with injury ruling out Alex Bass until the beginning of September as well as robbing Sam Hughes and Rio Adebisi of their entire seasons but things were only just getting started on that front.
It must have been hard for the great man to accept working with the inferior tools at his disposal at a club where he had previously won four promotions with swash-buckling, attacking sides, however, given his ringing endorsement of the club’s transfer policy, the turgid football being served up and the alarming downturn in results, he had to carry the can.
Defeat at home to Blackpool on October 25 led to the low point of the season; seeing the club’s greatest ever manager walk out of the door, for what we all believe is truly the final time. Posh sat bottom of the table and had only amassed ten points in 13 games. It’s likely that only Fergie’s legend status kept him in the job as long he was.
The realisation was starting to set in that a team who flirted with the drop last season could truly fall through the trapdoor this time around. To make matters worse, the disparity between the quality of player on show was at dramatic odds with the level fans were told they were at on a certain podcast. It is only so often you can bare to be told that a group who can justifiably have been called one of the worst sides in the league for large parts of the season, are one of the most talented in the division.
This squad was very close to taking Posh out of League One, just not in the direction that owner envisages.
Acceptance of the club’s true situation never seemed to set it in at the top- it was never communicated publicly if it did- and became increasingly jarring as we headed into the closing weeks with points still needed but the only reassurance coming was that Posh were merely a few key pieces away from a promotion push next time around.
Make up your mind on that but it does seem that plenty of individuals spent the season believing the hype given to them from the owner while doing next to nothing on the pitch to justify it.
Things did take a turn for the better at the end of October though when unquestionably the nicest man in football, Luke Williams, walked through the door. He brought with him the arm around the shoulder approach where many were perhaps used to the stern words of Ferguson.
It certainly appears that the players responded as Posh won all of Williams’ first four matches in charge. Reality then bit with four straight defeat but Posh bounced straight back with four wins in five over Christmas and New Year.
At the turn of the year, Posh were sat 11th just six points off the play-offs with a promotion charge firmly in their sights.
How realistic that is fans must decide themselves but Posh surrendered any chance at that and effectively threw the towel in on the season with the decision to make no January signings.
Maybe the feeling was that the squad was good enough as was to push for the top six, maybe the investment wasn’t seen as worth it and they were obviously safe and funds could be saved for the summer but whether you were being optimistic or pessimistic about the next 23 games, the holes in the squad were clear.
Where was the back up for Leonard? There was no-one trusted to play left wing other than Lisbie, Ben Woods was the senior only back-up to both Collins and Khela, there was one fit-left back at the club and if Lisbie, Garbett and Morgan could not be fielded as a three behind Leonard, there was an enormous drop-off in quality.
All of these concerns were cast aside and Posh chose to ride their luck. The club bet on black and the ball landed on red time and time again.
No-one likes blaming injuries but the time spent out by Harley Mills, Mendy, Okagbue, O’Connor, Lees, Woods, Garbett and Harry Leonard decimated the squad and brought the decision not to recruit in January into sharper focus. Posh were relying on academy lads, who had to be recalled from loan spells in the National League South and the tier below to lead the line. It was dire.
Still, there was an air of optimism that when these players returned things would improve and relegation wouldn’t even be a consideration. This is when the worries shifted from just this season into next.
With Posh sliding down the table- the slide was considerably slowed by Morgan stepping up when his side needed him most- a time came towards the end of March and beginning of April when players began to return. Leonard and Lees returned against Luton and Garbett two games later against Blackpool on April 11. This meant that Posh could field close to their “normal 11” again.
The problem is, Posh thumped Rotherham 5-0 at home on March 17 and then did not win again. That run will now stretch into this August; 15 games. The cavalry returned for Posh, there were “easy games” coming up such as the games in hand at home against ‘real’ strugglers Burton and Port Vale but still the results did not improve. Posh took just nine of the last 45 points available and did very little to help themselves.
Survival was left in the hands of Exeter, Leyton Orient and Wimbledon being worse sides than Posh. They were probably only worse sides between November and December but that was enough. It is this failure to finish with a flourish that has set the anxiety so high going into next season.
Posh had all the advantages given to them in the closing weeks of the season, returning players, games in hand, fixtures against struggling teams but they simply looked a rudderless, tactical inept mess with no confidence between them. They were offered a place in a lifeboat but said, no that’s ok, we’ll take our chances on this door being big enough and it was, just..
The sinking ship analogy better stop there as we all know where the Titanic ultimately ended up but the overriding emotion when Posh secured their safety against Mansfield, in the season’s penultimate game, was relief tinged with anger and disappointment, no celebrations. Playing to preserve that point was not pretty but sensible, a fact alone damning as to how low standards have sunk.
I don’t think there are a group of fans told how good their team is by their ownership more than Posh fans. The fact is, these players got the club’s greatest ever manager the sack and have made the owner look foolish with their performances this season.