We nominated centre-back Ryan Bennett and full-backs Mark Little and Tom Williams and they were just three of 32 different players subsequently nominated by you. Williams even nominated himself!
The players nominated covered all 60 years of Posh’s Football League era.
Here are the 15 players who received the most votes in reverse order, alongside one of their nominees.
9.
7th. KEN CHARLERY. Posh years: 1990-97. Apps: 224. Goals: 84. 'Ken Charlery up front with Ivan Toney would take some stopping. Lots of power there and plenty of goals' - @filltheblanks. | Johnston Press Photo: Midlands
10.
6th. DENNIS EMERY. Posh years: 1954-1963. Apps 308. Goals 231. 'Dennis Emery, playing just behind Ivan Toney as he would create chance after chance, while weighing in with a few goals of his own' - @john6anderson Photo: Midlands
11.
5th. MARK LITTLE. Posh years: 2009-2014. Apps 185. Goals 4. 'Mark Little in his prime. He could defend and was dynamite going forward' - @MattyAllan96. | Joe Dent/JMP Photo: Midlands
12.
4th. RYAN BENNETT. Posh years: 2009-2012. Apps: 100. Goals 7. 'Ryan Bennett at the heart of the defence. Calm head, cool in possession' - @The_real_Bats. Photo: Midlands