We nominated centre-back Ryan Bennett and full-backs Mark Little and Tom Williams and they were just three of 32 different players subsequently nominated by you. Williams even nominated himself!
The players nominated covered all 60 years of Posh’s Football League era.
Here are the 15 players who received the most votes in reverse order, alongside one of their nominees.
1.
15th. FREDDIE HILL. Posh years: 1973-75. Apps: 89. Goals: 8. . 'Freddie Hill. We don’t do enough from set pieces' - @AndrewS01534147.
2.
14th. BILLY KELLOCK. Posh years: 1979-1982. Apps: 256. Goals: 48. 'Billy Kellock was a smart player and got lots of goals from midfield' - @DeepingPoshFan. Photo: Midlands
3.
13th: SIMON DAVIES. Posh years: 1997-2000. Apps: 75. Goals. 6. 'Simon Davies because that would mean he could still make my national team (Wales) and play in a major tournament finals which is something he deserved' - @buckrodgersposh Photo: Midlands
4.
12th. CHRIS TURNER. Posh years: 1969-1978. Apps: 364. Goals: 43. 'Who else but The Messiah himself Chris Turner? Either on the field or off it. He would just own it' - @BudsterRob. Photo: Midlands