The beautiful game has turned ugly in League One, but the overall mediocrity gives me hope for Peterborough United

To the surprise of absolutely no-one who watches League One regularly, two of the five matches played yesterday finished 0-0.

Another one ended 1-0 as the latest drab day in a competition inhabited by primitive, limited football teams was played out. The beautiful game has turned ugly in the third tier.

The new Posh management team of Luke Williams and Ryan Harley. Photo David Lowndes.placeholder image
The new Posh management team of Luke Williams and Ryan Harley. Photo David Lowndes.

I blame Arsenal and a country full of copycat coaches. Just as Pep Guardiola’s brilliant Manchester City side sparked an obsession with footballing goalkeepers and defenders passing the ball sideways and backwards before venturing through the thirds, teams now see entertainment and excitement as optional extras rather than a priority.

Arsenal will win the Premier League this season based on scoring from set pieces and not conceding any goals. It will be a loveless coronation aside from one corner of North London.

Posh chairman Darragh MacAnthony described League One as ‘bizarre’ on his ‘Hard Truth’ podcast last week which is indeed a truth as few were predicting some of the early frontrunners, or indeed the early strugglers. I’d say ‘boring’ was more apt though, which includes the first 13 games of the Posh season. Even the team with a proud reputation for entertaining, eye-catching attacking football lost their way.

It’s now ‘keep-it-tight, five-at-the-back, try and win a set-piece, hoofball’ as far as I have seen, although leaders Stockport County might well prove to be an exception at London Road on Thursday night as they did at least deliver a quality 30 minutes in one game I watched on TV. The downside of so many lower league games available to watch live these days is exposing the utter rubbish on show, even when the leading sides clash. I still shudder at the memory of Bradford City 0, Lincoln City 0 last month.

Lincoln didn’t score in their next two League One games either, but went second yesterday after a late own goal delivered success against a rapidly fading Doncaster Rovers side. Bradford haven’t won any of their last five League One games and still sit third, one point off top.

The closeness throughout the division – Burton are 12th, just six points behind the leaders – screams mediocrity to me. Maybe ITV bosses know what they are doing when declining to run EFL highlights shows when the Championship is not taking place.

I cannot recall seeing one single outstanding forward player in League One games this season, although I missed the Posh game at Bolton who have winger Amario Cozier-Duberry lighting up their games with mazy dribbles and fantastic goals. He’s on loan from Brighton mind. I am looking forward to seeing Stockport’s Jack Diamond this week as well.

It’s that mediocrity that makes me confident Posh won’t go down. It’s even given me hope they can yet make an impact in the top half of the table, although for now I’d settle for being outside the relegation zone when the New Year arrives.

Even in the dark days of pre-Luke Williams I felt Posh had decent players in their squad come the end of August, but, through loyalty and respect for the previous boss, I was blind to the real issues, ones that have been quickly exposed by the managerial change.

I wouldn’t go as far as to predict Posh can make a late charge for the play-offs, although home wins against Stockport and fellow top six side Stevenage in the next 10 days, could change that mindset. Normally one team will plunge in the second-half of the season – Mansfield last season for instance – but I reckon half a dozen could suffer that fate this time around.

Steady form would enable Posh to pick them off one-by-one. How upwardly mobile they can become is anyone’s guess, but I am confident Posh will now become a better watch and that, plus 20th place, will do for now.

News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice