Peterborough United's huge managerial gamble with their immediate future

Robbie Savage. Photo by Alex Burstow/Getty Images.placeholder image
Robbie Savage. Photo by Alex Burstow/Getty Images.

Well, there we have it. Peterborough United have taken a huge gamble on their immediate future by appointing a manager with zero Football League experience.

It’s true all new managers come with risk attached, but handing the keys to the dressing room to Robbie Savage appears unnecessarily so. It’s a huge punt from a chairman making his 14th managerial appointment in 20 years when all but four have flopped, and the successes all had the same name.

Posh have overlooked managers – if of course they applied for the job – who have recently taken a team to the top of League One, won promotion from League One, and most pertinently perhaps, steered a side quickly away from the League One relegation zone. The latter one is Michael Duff who did that with Wycombe Wanderers last season after taking Barnsley to a League One play-off final earlier in his career.

Solid CVs in other words, but Posh have spurned a safe pair of hands in favour of a big personality, one who will bring a blaze of publicity with him as well as mocking noises from fans of rival clubs who will see a career record of a Northern Premier League Premier Division title with Macclesfield and a season-and-a-half of under achievement with Forest Green Rovers at National League level as a lead-up to relegation to League Two.

Robbie Savage points the way. Photo by Alex Burstow/Getty Images.placeholder image
Robbie Savage points the way. Photo by Alex Burstow/Getty Images.

Public support for the arrival of Savage has been on the increase in recent days. Former Posh managers and high-profile fans have weighed in with words like ‘exciting,’ ‘inspirational’ and a ‘perfect fit’ bandied about as well as claims of ‘research’ which have identified a love of attacking football. Little mention of results that match ambitions.

Savage left a well-financed Forest Green side in 12th place in the National League, one spot below Hornchurch, after a seventh-placed finish last season when they finished 27 points behind champions York City. Incidentally York were managed by Stuart Maynard who is now looking for work.

Savage supporters point to a strong-minded, passionate man who won’t suffer foolish football gladly – traits he certainly turned into a successful and lengthy playing career at the highest level – and who will be aggressive and demanding on the touchline. Mind you, Steve Evans was all of that, minus the playing stats, and Posh fans didn’t enjoy it all.

Savage supporters will also point to that playing career, one that will command instant respect from a young squad. That should be true, although it didn’t do a far superior player in Wayne Rooney any good when he took up management.

Robbie Savage. Photo by Eddie Keogh/Getty Imagesplaceholder image
Robbie Savage. Photo by Eddie Keogh/Getty Images

Savage supporters also point to the left-field appointment of Darren Ferguson at the start of MacAnthony’s reign and how well that turned out, but the comparison is moot as Fergie had no managerial baggage and he joined a club in League Two richer than most of their rivals with a dynamic can-do, will-do, must-do chairman. Chairman and manager rode the crest of a momentum wave in impressive fashion. Those dynamics are not in play now though.

We will find out what attracted Savage to MacAnthony soon enough, but having diametrically opposite characteristics to the previous manager could be a factor. It’s hard to imagine Savage standing on the touchline arms folded, free of passion, while watching dull football full of sideways and backwards passing before delivering anodyne, and baffling, post-match interviews.

Anyway MacAnthony has made his decision and true Posh fans are now duty bound to get behind it. I still bristle at fans who chose not to watch their club because Evans was the manager.

We have to ignore the bookies who think the opposite of a new manager bounce is about to happen. We must hope the new boss gives full focus to his day job by pausing his plentiful media work and that he can get enough positive results to ensure a serene relationship with MacAnthony rather than the combustible one many are fearing.

We must also hope he starts well as winning will make angry fans fall silent while the rest resume having positive thoughts. He starts with low expectations from many which may prove to be a blessing.

But there is a danger the Savage honeymoon will be short as three of his first four games are away from home, at Leicester City, Huddersfield Town and Bromley. Not winning the last one, or the one at home to Burton Albion in the middle of the run, and London Road and the Posh social media sphere won’t be pleasant places.

Fingers crossed that jumping up two levels to work with better players is the making of Savage the manager. Fingers crossed that a long odds-against flutter turns into a huge win. I wouldn’t bet on it though.

News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice