I was not surprised to see Peterborough United beaten at Bradford City on Saturday, the squad is just not ready for League One

I was not surprised to see Peterborough United beaten at Bradford on Saturday, the squad is just not ready, again….

It was a tough day for Posh in front of a bumper crowd and we can throw our hands up and say ‘well Bradford are a good side’, ‘they got to the play-offs last season’ and that is true- they will probably be up there again this season, even with the players that have lost, but for a start, that shows where the standards of the club have slipped in recent years.

James Dornelly battles for the ball against Bradford City. Photo by Joe Dent/Getty Images.placeholder image
James Dornelly battles for the ball against Bradford City. Photo by Joe Dent/Getty Images.

The more pressing issue is that Posh have not got their own house in order. We know that last season, the start was slow and that all of the cavalry that arrived to save the season came in the closing days and seconds of the summer window and it looks as if that will have to be the case again.

I don’t disagree with the chairman and manager when they say every manager will still want more at this stage. That is true but there is a difference between adding the finishing touches from a position of strength and leaving it late to scramble for players to ‘take the team to another level;’ to borrow a phrase from Luke Williams.

If Ethan Williams, Vernon Masara and Liam Kelly come off, the chairman will be vindicated in waiting for his targets and should be praised but that doesn’t negate the fact that the club are still suffering for multiple poor transfer windows over the last couple of years that has left the group short in almost all areas.

Posh were outplayed and outclassed for large parts of the game at Valley Parade, in my opinion, albeit there were moments and there were a handful of moments that could have led to goals. With the pace Posh do possess and the clinical finishing of Harry Leonard, there were weapons weapons to hit Bradford on the break and pose more of a threat but no way of making use of them. If Posh have built a team unable to distribute the ball to their biggest attacking threats, what is the point of them being there?

It is de je vu from Cardiff last season when you watch that team play and hope and pray that team isn’t the same one that is on the pitch come May. That wasn’t the case last time and Posh survived. We can only hope it is the same again.

Posh currently possess a squad full of holes, players who will need time to grow into the roles they have been asked to do and players who are just not suited to the roles they have been asked to do.

I can’t say a bad word about the club signing Tom O’Connor. His fitness will return in time and he was excellent amidst a sea of incompetence both beside and behind him yesterday. He was doing the job of three other players in the backline, all who worryingly, seemed to lack to basic instinct of what they were supposed to be doing. It does not surprise me that Posh only conceded from open play when O’Connor had to be withdrawn.

Posh have show faith in Harley Mills and James Dornelly to improve markedly. Have they improved as defenders since the first came on the scene? There was little evidence of it on show yesterday. Evan Weir appears to have been brought in to back up Mills rather than replace him and besides, he is the back-up centre back it seems with Williams not having the faith to bring young Lucca Mendonca into that environment when the time came to replace O’Connor.

So, potentially the best left-back is being used as centre-back cover. The best right-back is playing in midfield and appears to have jumped Ben Woods in the pecking order. Is the midfield shopping done? If so, surely a new right back is needed or else Dornelly will remain unopposed in that position. Kelly will take his starting place but if Williams wants Johnston as an off the bench option that would take him out of his defensive role.

Vernon Masara- who played his first game in professional football yesterday- is filling a similar duel role. He has been described as someone who can play anywhere across the front three. Therefore, at Valley Parade, he was the only striker and only winger on the bench. As is obvious, when he is required in one capacity, he can’t be used in the other and considering the youth of all of the wingers, I wouldn’t expect any of them to be regularly completing 90 minutes.

Behind the striker, Harrison Jones is making his first foray into the pro game at the ago of 21 after playing a negligible amount of games for Sunderland and he was backed up on the bench by the transfer-listed Chris Conn-Clarke. 18-year-old Patryk Sykut would have been the other option who would have staked a case to be on the bench and he in fact has played more first team matches than Jones (9 vs 8).

Posh seem to have put together a disjointed and unbalanced midfield. After the West Brom friendly, the BBC asked Williams what I must confess I thought to be a silly question, about whether Woods and Khela were in position to start in midfield on opening day. I mean, of course right…. but Williams said that no one was assured of a place and they haven’t indeed started together so far. That partnership has far from convinced me but Posh have a midfield that seems unable to distribute the ball to the places that need it. Khela is reaching a point is his career where he needs to start kicking on. He tries to do the right things but, as seen yesterday, frequently does not have the quality to play the passes that he sees. Johnston is a defender, he wants to win the ball and play a simple pass to get it out of his feet. Behind them, Okagbue does not possess the DNA of a Posh player and does not want the ball at his feet.

Maybe that is why Posh went direct but the midfield looked ineffective and was overrun. Lots of problems and not a lot of answers thus far, two games into the season. The squad looks unready for League One football, again.

News you can trust since 1948
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice