Here's my attempt at a starting XI with five substitutes.
It’s a pretty good side to be fair, although it’s full of attacking players in a 4-3-3 formation.
Those players who have played for both clubs who, perhaps unsurprisingly, didn’t make the squad include Ben Wright, Andrew Fotiadis, Shane Blackett, Kane Ferdinand, Liam Hatch, Lee Angol and Gregor Rioch.
My joint managers are Chris Turner and David Pleat. Turner played for both clubs, while Pleat was a Posh winger before becoming a very famous Luton Town manager.

13. DAVID OLDFIELD
Striker/midfielder for the subs bench. Posh signed him from Stoke City in 1999 and he was part of the Division Three play-off winning team at Wembley in May, 2000. He made 96 appearances in total scoring 5 goals. He made over 150 appearances for Luton before joining Stoke. Photo: s

14. JOE TAYLOR
Luton paid Posh a remarkable £500k for a striker who hadn't started a Football League match never mind scored a goal in January 2023. He played at Wembley in the Championship play-off final at the end of that season and scored from the spot in a penalty shootout win over Coventry City. Left Luton for Huddersfield Town after one start and is currently banging in the goals on loan at Wigan. He's on the bench for this combined team. Photo: David Lowndes

15. ADAM NEWTON
Versatile right-sided player for the subs bench. A steady Posh player for 249 appearances (9 goals) after joining from West Ham United in 2002. Left for Brentford in 2008 and then to Luton in 2009. Newton played more than 50 times for Luton. Photo: s

16. FRED BARBER
This promotion-winning goalkeeper left Posh for Luton and then returned to London Road on loan. He made 87 Posh appearances on total, but he's our back-up 'keeper to Mark Tyler. Photo: David Lowndes

