Political View: Can Government reorganisation offer any advantages for our residents?


With Local Government reorganisation being the hot topic Councillors are very much engaged with which option should be agreed as the City Council’s preference, writes Conservative Group deputy leader Steve Allen.
After several briefings over the past few months the choices have been slimmed down from the five options on offer at Octobers’ Joint Scrutiny meeting to a final two which were under consideration at an Extraordinary Full Council meeting on Wednesday evening.
Press deadlines prevent this comment piece confirming the outcome, but I fear the weight of numbers at the disposal of the current administration will see option D (Greater Peterborough) being the declared choice for Cabinet to rubber stamp on 18th November. (UPDATE: This was the chosen option).
We will most certainly see this worst of all options then taken forward for Government approval.


What could possibly go wrong?
A contrived choice – indeed a last-minute ill-conceived proposal from our two labour MP’s based on political expediency and ignoring all the declared guidelines. A proposal designed simply to ensure a likely Labour long term majority in a cobbled up Unitary Authority made up of just Peterborough and a few bits of Huntingdonshire!
This option ignores the object of the exercise which is to ensure the financial viability of the new unitary Councils and establishing a viable and sustained future for local Government.
So, an option cobbled up by Labour MP’s and pushed forward by a minority Labour Administration in our City, to a Labour Government with little understanding of the needs, requirements, and challenges of County Towns, Villages and a largely rural local government structure.
As the Conservative Group on Peterborough City County, we are in principle opposed to the proposals currently on offer, as they won’t offer any advantages for our residents, only inevitable upheaval.
We believe there will inevitably be a loss of local identity and responsiveness. With a larger unitary diluting the local element of local government.
On the other hand, the local Labour proposal simply offers an area too small to succeed and with a extended timescale unable to achieve any financial benefits.
On that basis if we must declare a preference it would be to the simple choice of Option A – this providing more immediate financial benefits, despite the obvious disadvantages of losing a functioning Authority, whist endeavouring to bring together disparate authorities, and at the same removing the advantages of having the district council tier – best able to feel the pulse of local needs and preferences.
In the public consultation the oft repeated issue from many contributors was to the effect that when decisions are made by people who don’t know the area and don’t understand the local character, you run the risk losing what people really value about where they live. Indeed, being merged into a larger unitary area might reduce Peterborough’s ability to make decisions tailored to its city context (rather than a broader region).
Against that point of view it must be understood balancing the cost of local government is the main driver of the restructuring exercise. In the end despite all the representations and variety of views being canvassed, the Government will make the decision based on finance.
We can only hope that this reality does provide a long-lasting and durable framework, and that short term political considerations will not be high on the agenda.
As for us in the Conservative Group we want no part of it given what’s on currently on the table. Our answer would be to cut costs, grow more as a city to generate the much-needed revenue and keep Peterborough’s identity intact.